Keyword Cannibalization: What It Is and How to Fix It

Ever heard of the term “cannibalization” in the SEO world? It sounds intense, doesn’t it? But don’t worry, we’re not talking about some dark, mysterious SEO ritual! In the context of SEO, keyword cannibalization is actually pretty common—and if you’re running a blog or website, there’s a good chance you might be experiencing it without even realizing it. Let’s dive into what keyword cannibalization really is, why it happens, and how you can address it effectively.

What is Keyword Cannibalization?

Keyword cannibalization happens when multiple pages or posts on your website are targeting the same keyword or keyword phrase. Essentially, instead of boosting your chances of ranking well in search results, your content ends up competing against itself. This situation often arises when a website has numerous articles or pages optimized around similar search terms, usually in an attempt to rank higher or cover more ground in the search results. Unfortunately, it can backfire by splitting the ranking potential across multiple pages.

So, Why Is This a Problem?

When Google encounters multiple pages on your site with similar content targeting the same keywords, it can struggle to determine which page to rank higher. The result? Your pages might fluctuate in ranking, or worse, all may end up ranking lower than they otherwise could. It’s as if each page is “eating away” at the other’s chance to shine.

Some common signs of keyword cannibalization include:

• Inconsistent or fluctuating rankings.
• Lower overall rankings for related keywords.
• A drop in organic traffic.

Why Does Keyword Cannibalization Happen?

Keyword cannibalization usually isn’t intentional. In fact, it’s often the result of well-meaning SEO efforts. Here are some common reasons why it happens:

1. Content Growth Over Time: As your blog or website grows, it’s natural to create content on topics that may overlap. Over time, you might have several posts with similar themes or keywords without realizing they’re competing for the same keyword.
2. Similar Intent or Topic: Sometimes, different pieces of content can have slightly different angles but end up optimized for similar search terms. For example, if you have posts on “SEO Tips,” “SEO Best Practices,” and “SEO Advice,” they may unintentionally target the same keywords.
3. Internal Linking Issues: Internal links can help Google understand the relationship between pages, but linking similar articles in a way that suggests they’re all equally relevant for the same keyword can actually create competition between them.
4. Overuse of Broad Keywords: Often, websites inadvertently use broad or general keywords across multiple pages, thinking that more is better. In reality, this leads to content overlap and keyword cannibalization.
5. SEO Over-Optimization: In the quest to rank for multiple terms, it’s easy to create multiple pages around similar search terms without a clear, unique focus.

How Does Keyword Cannibalization Affect SEO?

Here’s why keyword cannibalization can be detrimental to your SEO strategy:

• Lower Rankings: Instead of having one strong page that ranks high for a target keyword, you have multiple weaker pages that dilute the ranking potential. Google has to decide which page is most relevant, often resulting in lower rankings for all competing pages.
• Reduced Click-Through Rates (CTR): If multiple pages rank on the same keyword but don’t stand out individually, it can reduce the chances of users clicking through, as none appear to be the “go-to” resource on the topic.
• Wasted Crawl Budget: Googlebot crawls each page on your site, and if you have multiple pages covering similar topics, you could be wasting your crawl budget, which can impact how often Google indexes your content.

How to Identify Keyword Cannibalization

Now that we know what keyword cannibalization is, the next step is figuring out if it’s an issue on your site. Here are a few ways to identify it:

1. Google Search: Start by typing “site
   .com [keyword]” into Google. This will show you all the pages from your site that are ranking for that specific keyword. If you see multiple pages appearing for a single keyword, that could indicate cannibalization.
2. Google Search Console: Under the “Performance” tab in Search Console, check if you have multiple URLs ranking for similar keywords. You can export the data to easily see if any pages overlap.
3. SEO Tools: Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Moz allow you to look up keywords by URL or domain, making it easy to see if multiple pages are optimized for the same keywords.
4. Content Audit: Regularly auditing your content can help identify keyword overlaps. Make a list of all your blog posts, noting the main keywords targeted by each, and check for duplicates.

How to Fix Keyword Cannibalization

Now for the good part—how to solve keyword cannibalization on your website! Here are a few effective strategies:

1. Consolidate Content

If you have multiple pages targeting the same keyword or topic, consider combining them into one comprehensive piece. This approach not only prevents cannibalization but also enhances user experience by providing a single resource that covers everything a reader might need.

For example, let’s say you have two blog posts: “SEO Tips for Beginners” and “Basic SEO Advice.” You could combine them into a single, more in-depth article, like “Complete SEO Tips and Advice for Beginners.”

2. Use Canonical Tags

If you can’t consolidate the pages, consider using canonical tags to tell Google which page you want to be the primary one. This way, Google understands that one page is the main source and doesn’t split ranking efforts across multiple similar pages.

3. Refocus Content on Different Keywords

Adjust the keywords of each page to avoid overlap. For example, if you have two posts on similar topics, make sure each targets a distinct keyword. You might optimize one post for “SEO Strategies” and the other for “SEO Tools.”

4. Improve Internal Linking Structure

Use internal links strategically to indicate to Google which pages are the most important. For example, if you have a cornerstone page on “SEO Tips,” link to it from related posts. This signals to Google that this page is the authoritative source on the topic.

5. Adjust On-Page SEO

If your pages are competing due to on-page elements like titles, headings, and meta descriptions, revise them to make each page unique. Avoid using the exact same title tag or meta description across multiple pages.

6. Create a Content Hierarchy

If your site covers a lot of related topics, consider creating a content hierarchy or “silo” structure. For example, if you have multiple articles on SEO, create a single “SEO Guide” page that links to more specific articles, such as “SEO for Beginners” and “Advanced SEO Strategies.” This way, Google sees the guide as the primary page, and the specific articles as supporting content.

Preventing Keyword Cannibalization in the Future

Once you’ve fixed existing issues, you’ll want to prevent keyword cannibalization going forward. Here are some tips to keep it at bay:

• Plan a Keyword Strategy: Before publishing new content, have a clear keyword strategy that avoids overlap. Assign specific keywords to specific pages to prevent targeting the same terms.
• Create Unique, In-Depth Content: Whenever possible, create comprehensive content that thoroughly covers a topic rather than splitting it across multiple posts.
• Use Content Silos: Organize your content in a way that makes it clear which pages are the main resources and which are supplementary.
• Monitor Regularly: Periodically check for keyword cannibalization as your site grows. A content audit every few months can help catch and address issues before they impact rankings.

Keyword Cannibalization

Keyword cannibalization might sound intimidating, but once you understand it, it’s easy to tackle. The key is to take a proactive approach: know what each piece of content is targeting, and create a clear structure that tells Google exactly which page is most important for each keyword.

By identifying and fixing keyword cannibalization on your site, you’ll not only improve your SEO rankings but also provide a better experience for your readers. After all, it’s much more user-friendly to have one comprehensive resource than multiple pages covering similar ground. So go ahead—streamline your content, optimize your pages, and watch as your rankings and user experience improve!

Interesting Reads:

SEO Boosters for WooCommerce: Rank Higher & Sell More

How to Build an Adaptive SEO Strategy That Thrives

Unlocking Success: A Comprehensive SEO Guide for Coaches