In the fast-evolving world of YouTube, staying ahead of platform changes is critical for content creators. With Shorts continuing to dominate attention spans and generate billions of views monthly, creators are asking an important question in 2025: Do YouTube Shorts thumbnails really matter anymore?
The rise of vertical video has reshaped content strategy. Shorts offer creators a new way to grow audiences quickly, even without traditional long-form production. But while Short’s focus is on fast, vertical storytelling, many creators are unsure whether custom thumbnails are still relevant—or even worth the effort.
After all, when a viewer is swiping through the Shorts feed, thumbnails are completely invisible. Unlike standard YouTube videos that rely heavily on thumbnails for clicks, Shorts begin playing instantly in a scrollable feed. So if viewers never see the thumbnail, what’s the point?
Yet in contexts beyond the Shorts feed, thumbnails still play a vital role. From search visibility to branding, YouTube Shorts thumbnail best practices are becoming more important for creators who want to build sustainable growth on the platform. In this article, we’ll break down when thumbnails make a difference, how YouTube displays Shorts across its ecosystem, and why thumbnails are still a powerful tool in your creative toolkit.
What Are YouTube Shorts Thumbnails?
Before diving into their importance, let’s define what we mean by a YouTube Shorts thumbnail. A thumbnail is a static image—often custom-designed—that represents the video in various parts of the YouTube interface. For long-form videos, thumbnails are key to attracting clicks. For Shorts, thumbnails are optional, and their effectiveness varies based on where the Short appears.
When you upload a Short, YouTube automatically selects a frame from your video to use as its thumbnail. However, creators uploading via desktop have the option to upload a custom thumbnail manually. On mobile, this option may be limited or unavailable.
Where Do YouTube Shorts Thumbnails Appear in 2025?
Despite not showing up in the Shorts feed itself, custom thumbnails still appear across several strategic locations on the platform:
- Your Channel Page
When users visit your channel, they’re likely to browse the “Videos” tab, where both Shorts and long-form content are listed. Here, custom thumbnails are clearly displayed. A compelling thumbnail can entice viewers to click on your Short instead of scrolling past.
- Search Results
Shorts increasingly appear in YouTube search results, especially when titles are keyword-optimized. In this view, Shorts show thumbnails alongside long-form videos, giving creators a chance to stand out. A high-quality thumbnail can boost your click-through rate (CTR), even if the content is under 60 seconds.
- Suggested Video Feeds
On the homepage and in the suggested videos sidebar (especially on desktop), Shorts can show up with thumbnails. When Shorts perform well in terms of engagement or align with a user’s watch history, YouTube may promote them outside the Shorts feed, where thumbnails once again matter.
- Playlists and Series
If you organize your Shorts into playlists or series, thumbnails help create a cohesive visual identity. This is particularly useful for episodic content or thematic Shorts collections. Viewers scrolling through playlists are influenced by strong visual previews.
- External Platforms
When Shorts are shared outside of YouTube—via social media, blogs, newsletters, or embedded on websites—the thumbnail often appears as the preview image. Without a thumbnail, the video may look incomplete or visually unappealing.
Thumbnails and the Shorts Feed: What Doesn’t Matter
Thumbnails indeed have no impact inside the native Shorts feed. The moment a viewer starts scrolling through Shorts on mobile, they are shown videos in a vertical, full-screen format with instant autoplay. There’s no thumbnail preview. This is why many creators believe thumbnails are obsolete for Shorts.
However, focusing solely on the Short feed misses a key opportunity. YouTube’s ecosystem is more than just one feed—and smart creators understand that Shorts can drive traffic from multiple entry points.
The Algorithm’s Perspective
While thumbnails are not a direct ranking factor for Shorts in the Shorts feed, they influence performance through secondary signals. For example:
- A higher click-through rate from search or channel pages increases Short’s chances of being recommended further.
- More engagement and longer watch sessions from viewers who discovered the video through its thumbnail can result in YouTube pushing that Short to wider audiences.
Essentially, thumbnails help Shorts succeed outside the Shorts feed, and those additional views feed into the video’s overall performance metrics.
What the Data Shows
YouTube hasn’t released granular data specific to Shorts thumbnails. But platform tools like TubeBuddy, vidIQ, and analytics shared by top creators give us useful insights:
- Creators who use consistent, branded thumbnails for Shorts often see stronger subscriber growth and higher CTR from their channel pages.
- Shorts with compelling thumbnails are more likely to appear in suggested videos and external links, leading to secondary discovery.
- Custom thumbnails help reinforce a channel’s visual identity, leading to better retention and repeat viewers.
These patterns suggest that while thumbnails aren’t universally impactful, they’re strategically important, especially for creators treating Shorts as part of a broader channel strategy.
What Top Creators Are Doing in 2025
Many leading YouTubers continue to invest in Shorts thumbnails despite their limited visibility in the feed.
- MrBeast uses thumbnails for Shorts that are consistent with his long-form style—clean, expressive, and emotionally engaging.
- Ali Abdaal creates Shorts that match his channel’s color scheme and typography, making them recognizable at a glance.
- Educational and commentary channels use bold text, clear visuals, and branded overlays—even for Shorts.
Their reason? Even if thumbnails don’t impact every view, they still influence perception, brand trust, and visibility across the platform.
Should You Create Custom Thumbnails for Shorts?
Let’s break it down:
Create Thumbnails If:
- You want your channel to have a consistent, professional look.
- You regularly appear in search or suggested videos.
- You use Shorts to introduce viewers to your channel.
- You plan to share Shorts externally or embed them elsewhere.
- You organize content into playlists or series.
You Might Skip Thumbnails If:
- You publish high-volume, daily Shorts focused only on the Shorts feed discovery.
- Your Shorts are meant to be disposable or experimental.
- You’re limited to mobile uploads and can’t design thumbnails consistently.
Still, even in these cases, having a basic branded template can go a long way.
Best Practices for Short Thumbnails
If you decide to create custom thumbnails, keep these best practices in mind:
- Use Correct Dimensions
Standard YouTube thumbnail dimensions still apply: 1280×720 pixels, 16:9 aspect ratio. Yes, even for Shorts.
- Prioritize Simplicity
Use bold visuals, close-up faces, and large text that stands out on all screen sizes. Avoid clutter.
- Maintain Brand Consistency
Use the same fonts, colors, and design elements across your content. This builds trust and recognition.
- Optimize for Search and Channel Views
Design thumbnails that make sense out of context. A viewer seeing your Short in a search result should immediately understand its value.
- Test and Adjust
Track CTR for Shorts appearing in search or on your channel. Tweak thumbnails to see what performs best.
The Bigger Picture: Shorts as Part of Channel Strategy
Thumbnails are just one piece of a bigger puzzle. As YouTube continues integrating Shorts into the main channel experience—via playlists, search, and even monetization—creators must treat Shorts not as isolated viral clips, but as integral parts of their content strategy.
Thumbnails reinforce storytelling, visual identity, and professionalism. They help Shorts live longer and perform better beyond the feed.
Final Verdict: Do Thumbnails Matter?
In 2025, the answer is clear:
Yes, YouTube Shorts thumbnails still matter—but not in the way you might think.
They don’t affect autoplay views in the Shorts feed. But they influence visibility, discoverability, and branding everywhere else. For creators focused on growth, subscriber engagement, and long-term value, thumbnails remain a smart investment.
If you’re just starting out, don’t let perfect thumbnails slow you down. But as you grow, think of thumbnails as strategic assets. The creators who treat Shorts like full-fledged content, not throwaway clips, are the ones who will win the long game.
Interesting Reads:
Best Text to Movie Converters: Turn Your Words into Cinematic Experiences
5 Best AI Art Tools For Making Youtube Thumbnails
Best Practice Tips To Optimize YouTube Videos For High Rankings
